The Short Stories of Edmund Crispin – Part 2: The Later Works

Back to Crispin’s ingenious and oft-neglected short stories. Last time I looked at Crispin’s early short works and this week I will look at the collecting in Fen Country, which spans the later period of his writing from 1952-1979.

Love these 70’s covers with the painstaking composition or real objects. Including in this case a stuffed cats claw.

A tiny acknowledgements page at the back tells us that Fen Country is compiled of three different collections. Firstly, many of the 26 stories on offer are from the period between 1950 and 1955 where Crispin was writing stories for the London Evening Standard (oh, to have this back again!). Two stories are taken from editions of Ellery Queens Mystery magazine, and two are taken from a collection called Winter’s Crimes, a series that I have heard a little about but would appreciate more info from those in the know. The first volume is on sale on ebay currently at £103, so it’s a rarity now?

As with Beware Of The Trains each story takes one simple problem, or one very clever and specific idea and uses that as a fulcrum for the tale. I was told by my good friend JJ of The Invisible Event  said he felt that the stories here in Fen Country didn’t contain as good plotting, but the ideas were amazing. And that is a really good way to describe it. The shockingly rigorous plotting of Beware of the Trains is not at play here, but it seems like Crispin was having a huge amount of fun, and being much bolder in experimenting, with the central concept used for each tale. There is a focus on the modernist, meta experimentations that Crispin was so good at with his novels, but pushing them to the limit. One story plays with the idea that Crispin himself is the main characters, and plays with your expectations in the reader/author relationship.


Here are my tops tales from the collection:

Who Killed Baker – (1950)
Simply a genius piece of work. This is the first in the collection and kicks things off so well as it shows where Crispin had got to in terms of manipulating the form and subverting the form. Crispin was clearly having a lot of fun here, and I’m sure this story might ruffle a few feathers. I can’t say too much more but the whole piece revolves around the simple statement ‘Who Killed Baker?’ (Geoffrey Bush?)

The Hunchback Back Cat – (1954)
‘Were ALL superstitious… whether we realise it or not. Let me give you a test’. This is Gervase Fen’s opening gambit in a story that again could have made a full novel with all that is crammed into it. It tells the story of the Copping family, a family who, due to parricidal tendencies and tragedies, there are only two left of. The murder of one of them in a locked tower (very reminiscent in description of the room in Jonathan Creek’s The Grinning Man), leads to a wonderful set of double and triple bluffs that I never saw coming. How the superstitious angle closes the case is extremely clever.

A Case in Camera – (1955)
Detective Inspector Humbleby, Crispin’s series detective inspector in the Gervase Fen stories, is keeping a case open against his superior’s wishes. His intuition has convinced him, for the moment, that the suspects statements are a little too consistent. Their alibi rests on a single photograph which places them elsewhere at the time of a brutal murder. How Fen catches them out is such a lovely idea, and again feels like one of those simple happenings that Crispin saw or experienced in day to day life, and sculpted it to be a tale of crime. This type of writing feels very Carrian, and as I have mentioned elsewhere Crispin was inspired to take up the mystery field after reading Carr.


The Pencil – (1953)
When discussing this collection with fellow blogger JJ, this was the story that came to mind for him, and it’s no surprise. Spy thriller in style, The Pencil opens with a contract killer, known only as Elliot, being kidnapped by two assailants, all of which he know would happen and so has planned accordingly.  It has an absolute kicker of an ending and in four pages does more than some novels manage to do!

Death Behind Bars – (1960)
A longer, non series piece, Murder Behind Bars considers how a man being held on suspicion of murder is killed in his locked cell. There is no way of approaching the cell in the time specified, and the murder weapon is no where to be found. Although in ,many ways you can see the solution coming, I really loved it, and it has been used a lot since (and maybe was before). I even saw it in a recent episode of The Dr Blake mysteries even though it wasn’t a locked room scenario. And the motives are especially well spun in this one. But what makes this story even more brilliant is the form that the piece takes, and how that brings everything home to you as the reader, but I’ll let you experience that for yourself.

We Know You’re Busy Writing, But We Thought You Wouldn’t Mind If We Just Dropped in for a Minute – (1969) 
A deliciously dark story, clearly based on the frustrations that Crispin experienced being a writer. The setting is a small, isolated cottage in Devon which is exactly where Crispin lived and worked. The story tells us of one Mr Bradley a writer of adventure stories who has a deadline to meet, but keeps receiving endless interruptions of all kinds at his lonely cottage. The characters here are superb, and the way that Bradley desperately tries to remember the line he was writing as he is interrupted is hilarious. The closing line however, is one of the most chilling you’ll read in a short mystery.

Those are my top stories. I highly recommend this collection. Although they are a mixed bag, I think much of this was down to restrictions in time and word count, especially for the Evening Standard pieces. This struggle for deadlines is something that Crispin showed in full in ‘We Know You’re Busy Writing…’, maybe it was a confessional piece of sorts? If you see this on your travels pick it up!







16 thoughts on “The Short Stories of Edmund Crispin – Part 2: The Later Works”

  1. I’ve just started my re-reading of Crispin, but had not thought about trying the short story collections, which I read years ago (and of course me being me remember nothing about). I think though that your post is certainly strongly persuading me to add at least one SS collection to my re-read list. Which would you say is the strongest collection? Beware of Trains or Fen Country?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I would say Beware of the Trains is the stronger collection overall. It seems Crispin spent more time on these works and maybe write them for himself rather than for quick demand of the newspaper. Almost all of the BOTT series could have been made into a novel or novella.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Thanks for the review, and it looks like I need to grab a copy of these stories off my Kindle store – but for some reason this collection is priced twice as much as every other Crispin title! 😭

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That terrible news! I was lucky enough to come cross this second hand. There is one story here which is unpublished anywhere else which may account for the cost? (But who knows with many of these things?!)


  3. Interesting reading, and you’ve picked several of my favourite stories as highlights. The one I’d disagree on is “We Know You’re Busy…”, but that’s not because it’s not well-written, it’s simply because it’s the type of crime fiction I don’t like.

    I would agree with you that “Beware of the Trains” is more satisfying of the two collections. Several of the “Fen Country” stories are of the Ellery Queen “fun and games” ilk – very short stories that just posits a conundrum and then resolves it all within a few pages. Pure puzzles. Meanwhile, all the stories in BOTT are fleshed out more and thus work better as stories.

    A few years ago, I read somewhere that there are in fact other Crispin stories floating around in magazines that were not collected in either of these two collections. Do you know whether this is correct? If so, a third Crispin collection would immediately be added to my wishlist of what collections should be published in the future…

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks Christian, glad we are agreed on much of this. For sure ‘We Know You’re Busy..’ is really a mini thriller more than anything, so if that’s not your thing I can get that.

      Not sure about another Crispin collection or where further ones may be. I’ll ask around and see if I can find out for you.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Any information would be of value. 🙂

        Dunno if I’d call ”Busy” a thriller, to be honest. It’s one of those crime novels, though a short story. It just describes a crime. No mystery, no detection. No adventure, no action scenes.

        ’Cause thrillers, particularly action thrillers, are definitely my thing…

        Liked by 1 person

    2. Chatted to some expert friends over on the Golden Age Detection FB group, and someone said that there are a number of unpublished shorts and a radio play and that there is something coming out about them in CADS magazine later this year (are you familiar with CADS?). Another friend told me that there is also an uncollected ghost story titled ‘St Bartholomew’s Eve’ and is a pastiche of the work of M R James. Hope that helps!


      1. Thanks for your efforts! In a way, it’s both good and bad to hear that there are no (or just one) uncollected published short stories out there.

        I know OF CADS, though I’ve never read it myself. But now I might have to look out for the issue where these Crispin stories are discussed. 🙂


  4. Just by chance, I came across this post and noted the question regarding the uncollected short stories of Edmund Crispin.
    The following are the short stories of Edmund Crispin not available in the 2 collections:
    (The reference to EQMM is to the USA edition)
    1. All in the way you look at it (EQMM April 1953)
    2. Blackmailers have their uses (EQMM July 1955)
    3. The Crime by the river (EQMM March 1955)
    4. Looking for a diamond (EQMM October 1955)
    5. A message to Herr Dietrich (EQMM November 1955)
    6. Nine minus nine equals one (EQMM March 1951)
    7. St. Bartholomew’s Day (EQMM February 1975)
    8. Too clever for Scotland Yard (EQMM September 1960)
    9. The Unloaded Gun (The Saint Detective Magazine September 1955)
    10. What is his line ? (EQMM May !956}

    All the above stories except at 3, 7, and 8 involve Gervase Fen.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. With regard to the “uncollected stories”:

    1. All in the way you look at it (EQMM April 1953) – same as “Otherwhere”
    2. Blackmailers have their uses (EQMM July 1955) – same as “Man Overboard”
    3. The Crime by the river (EQMM March 1955) – same as “The House by the River”
    4. Looking for a diamond (EQMM October 1955) – same as “Dog in the Night-Time”
    5. A message to Herr Dietrich (EQMM November 1955) – same as “Outrage in Stepney”
    6. Nine minus nine equals one (EQMM March 1951) – same as “Beware of the Trains”
    7. St. Bartholomew’s Day (EQMM February 1975) – uncollected
    8. Too clever for Scotland Yard (EQMM September 1960) – same as “Death Behind Bars”
    9. The Unloaded Gun (The Saint Detective Magazine September 1955) – same as “Humbleby Agonistes”
    10. What’s his line ? (EQMM May 1956} – same as “Occupational Risk”

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: